Trial Lawyers Serving Kentucky & Indiana

Request Your FREE Consultation 502-657-7100

The elements of negligence in a personal injury case

The four elements of negligence in a personal injury case are duty of care, breach of duty, causation, and damages. To recover, you have to show someone owed you reasonable care, fell short of it, and caused harm because of that negligence.

Getting hurt in a crash is frightening, and the bills start before the answers do. A Louisville personal injury lawyer at Grossman Green PLLC can tell you which of the four is likely to be contested in your case.

Man injured at work - The elements of negligence in a personal injury case

What are the four elements, and which one usually decides a case?

Negligence means failing to use reasonable care and causing harm. In Kentucky, the injured party has to prove all four elements of negligence: duty, breach, causation, and damages.

  • Duty of care. The defendant owed you a legal duty to act with reasonable care.
  • Breach of duty. They fell short of that duty.
  • Causation. Their carelessness caused your injuries.
  • Damages. You suffered real losses.

Every element of negligence has to hold.  Usually, duty is easy to prove, but it can be difficult to prove breach and causation in some cases.

The other driver may deny doing anything wrong. Or they may admit the mistake and argue it did not cause your injuries. That second argument comes up more than people expect, especially when an injured party had a pre-existing medical condition. Medical records and witness statements are what answer it.

How does Kentucky law help prove the defendant’s breach?

Kentucky drivers owe everyone else on the road reasonable care. That means paying attention, keeping to the speed limit, signaling turns, and following traffic laws. Break those rules, and you may breach that duty at the same time.

Drivers are the common example, but not the only one. A store owes its customers reasonable care about a wet floor, and a trucking company owes drivers on the road appropriately-rested truck drivers. The legal duty shifts with the relationship. The other three elements work the same way regardless.

Kentucky also recognizes a legal theory called negligence per se. Under KRS 446.070, a person injured by the violation of a statute can recover for that violation. The statute has to be one meant to protect people like you from the kind of harm that happened. When it fits, the defendant’s breach gets easier to show, because the broken law does some of the proving for you.

What if the other driver ran a red light?

Running a red light is a clean example. Under KRS 189.338, a driver facing a circular red has to stop at the stop line and stay there until a green shows, with narrow exceptions for certain turns. Breaking that rule can help establish a breach.

You still have to show how the crash happened and what it did to you. Police reports and traffic tickets help. So do photos, video, traffic camera footage, and witness statements. Medical records connect the crash to the injury. A personal injury attorney will attempt to find camera footage early, because it is not always kept for long.

What counts as damages in a Kentucky injury claim?

Damages are the losses the injury caused you. Kentucky injury claims cover two kinds.

Economic damages are the ones with paperwork behind them. Medical bills and future treatment costs. Lost wages from missed work, plus reduced earning ability if the injury is lasting. Property damage to your car or your bike.

The other kind covers what the injury did to your life. Pain and suffering, emotional distress, the loss of things you used to enjoy, and the strain on the people around you. None of that comes with a receipt, which is why witness testimony, medical records, receipts, and your own account of a changed routine carry so much weight.

What if you were partly at fault for the crash?

You can still recover. Kentucky courts use pure comparative fault, which means blame can be shared and sharing it does not end your personal injury claim.

KRS 411.182 is the statute that sorts out who bears what share. Your own share comes off your recovery. So let’s say your damages total $10,000, and you are found 20% at fault. You recover $8,000.

There is no cutoff in Kentucky.   It also cuts the other way, so an insurer has a reason to argue your share is larger than it is.

Hurt in Louisville and unsure what you would have to prove? Talk with Grossman Green PLLC

After an injury, you are thinking about your health and your bills, and whether your family will be all right. That is a lot to carry while also learning what a claim requires.

Grossman Green PLLC works with injured people in Louisville and handles a claim from the first call through appeal, so you deal with your attorney rather than a case manager. We will investigate the crash and take the insurer’s calls. Kentucky’s injury claim deadlines keep running while all of this gets sorted out, which is the practical reason not to sit on it.

Call us at (502) 657-7100 or contact us online to request a free consultation. We will walk through what your case would need and what the process is likely to involve.

Related Posts